LIVE Tuesday, November 17, 2026 DOW ▲ +0.42% S&P 500 ▲ +0.65% NASDAQ ▲ +0.81%
BBBBFNEWS
BBBBF News – Breaking World, U.S. & Business Headlines
Real-time international reporting, market trends, technological breakthroughs, and in-depth global perspectives.
ALERT
WORLD

‘Half measures will not do’: Milburn calls for wholesale reform as he publishes major youth unemployment report – live

‘Half measures will not do’: Milburn calls for wholesale reform as he publishes major youth unemployment report – live

‘We are failing as a nation to gift young people, the next generation, the opportunities they need to succeed,’ Alan Milburn says

Full story: Milburn says plan will save only £200m a year

Milburn releases report to tackle NEET crisis – watch liveFrom 32m agoMilburn is restating a case that he has been making in public for months now – that there is a moral case for tackling the Neet crisis.

A lost generation is not a fact of life. It’s a choice. And I believe it’s the wrong one. Not just because it’s a fiscal crisis or an economic one, because it’s a moral crisis.

We are failing as a nation to gift young people, the next generation, the opportunities they need to succeed.

We forecast that within five years, Neet numbers will be well above 1 million and indeed will be an excess of 1.25 million.

So the conclusion I’ve come to is that half measures will not do. The scale of the problem is just too big for that.

We have reached a profound moment of choice for the country. It calls for a new approach to back the next generation, to make young people a top priority.

Q: [From Ryan Sabey from the Sun] What is your advice to the PM about negotiating a youth mobility scheme with the EU? Will that help young people get a job?

Milburn says young people in British communities must come first. There has been an over-dependence on migrant labour. But the fall in migration creates an opportunity, he says.

Q: If you were offered a job to implement this, would you accept?

I’ve done my review. Let’s see what happens next. But obviously I’m not going to walk away from this.

You know, I care about it. I’ve cared about it for countless years – I was going to say decades, but it probably is decades. So let’s see where that goes.

Milburn says he is a member of a generation that has been lucky.

I’ve been incredibly lucky in my life. I grew up on a council estate, and I had the fortune to end up serving in the cabinet.

I’m part of a generation that has, by and large, done pretty well. We entered a labour market where the first rung of the career ladder was easier to reach. For many of us, housing was more affordable. We benefited from expanded educational opportunities.

Like so many other people of my generation, I was the first in my family to go to university and we inherited a simple promise from our parents.

But the promise on offer to young people in the past is now broken, he says.

Work hard and you build a better life. That great British promise for this generation is being broken.

The response to the interim report we published in May has convinced me. There is a visceral mood for change in the country. Parents and grandparents feel it. Employers feel it. Politicians feel it too. They all know that the risk of a lost generation of young people is real.

Being Neet used to be something that happened to other people’s children. Now, when a third of young people who are Neet have five good GCSEs, when 15% of them have a degree, parents are wondering whether it’s going to happen to their son or their daughter.

Milburn restates his view that, over time, his proposals will produce savings for the state. (See 9.04am and 11.36am.)

He says he did consider trying to cut costs more quickly.

I‘ve looked long and hard at whether more could be achieved earlier. It could, but only through crude benefit cuts without the accompanying support.

I do not believe that it’s defensible morally, any more than I believe it will work fiscally. It would plunge more young people into destitution, and the costs would simply show up in another part of the state’s balance sheet in increased spending on housing or health or crime.

So I believe the approach I advocate is both radical and, critically, it’s doable.

Milburn is still giving his opening speech. He is summarising his proposals. (See 11.58am.)

He claims the biggest problem over the past 50 years has been relying on supply-side economics alone to tackle youth unemployment.

The biggest fallacy, in my view, in public policy over 50 years, is that the youth employment problem could be solved purely by fixing the supply side, make the young person more employable, raise the standards in the schools, improve their skills, toughen their benefits. The labour market, it was assumed, would then do all the heavy lifting and get young people into work.

It hasn’t. Employment has risen. Youth employment has fallen without a change in direction. Rebuilding the first rung of that career ladder will not happen. Government needs to focus on the demand side as much as on the supply. A new bargain is needed with employers to create more first chances for young people.

These days, when the government releases a policy document, it is always keen to publish quotes from “stakeholders”. This morning the Department for Work and Pensions has released a long list of supportive, or partially supportive quotes. Here are a few of them.

From Allen Simpson, chief executive of UK Hospitality

This is a rightly ambitious plan to solve the Neets crisis. Hospitality, as the largest employer of young people in the economy, stands ready to provide young people with the job opportunities they need to be part of the work generation. I’ve been delighted to have worked closely with the review team, and I look forward to working with the government on taking these plans forward.

From Tina McKenzie, national chair of the Federation of Small Businesses

The government was right to make this a national priority and appoint Alan Milburn. We are pleased to see his report published and we call on Ministers to take up the action needed to help employers and those looking for work.

Bringing forward support for young people who have been economically inactive for too long and giving them a genuine chance to gain experience and build confidence, is an important step and small businesses are well placed as long as public policy decisions now flow from the review.

From Helen Dickinson, chief executive of the British Retail Consortium said:

Milburn rightly recognises the critical role retail can play in tackling the youth crisis and the need to reduce the cost of entry level jobs for young people. Retail provides accessible routes into work and the skills to progress. With a million young people not earning or learning, the need for action has never been greater. Retailers are playing their part through a new national retail work experience programme, Opening Shift, helping Neets break the ‘no experience, no job’ cycle.

But experience is not enough if there is no job at the end of it. Government must head Milburn’s call and make it easier for businesses to hire, train, and invest in the next generation.

From Jon Sparkes OBE, chief executive of Mencap

This is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to back young people and invest in them so they can realise their potential. We know young people with a learning disability want to work, but the system fails to provide them with the opportunity and tailored support to do so.

Both the Opportunity and Employment Guarantees recommended in this review will make a real difference, as will joined up support with health and education services.

From Lynn Perry, chief executive of Barnardo’s

Across the UK, a million young people are being denied the opportunity to fulfil their potential. This week must mark a watershed moment, where as a society we commit to a better future for this generation.

Here is Peter Walker’s summary of what’s in the Milburn report.

Milburn is restating a case that he has been making in public for months now – that there is a moral case for tackling the Neet crisis.

A lost generation is not a fact of life. It’s a choice. And I believe it’s the wrong one. Not just because it’s a fiscal crisis or an economic one, because it’s a moral crisis.

We are failing as a nation to gift young people, the next generation, the opportunities they need to succeed.

We forecast that within five years, Neet numbers will be well above 1 million and indeed will be an excess of 1.25 million.

So the conclusion I’ve come to is that half measures will not do. The scale of the problem is just too big for that.

We have reached a profound moment of choice for the country. It calls for a new approach to back the next generation, to make young people a top priority.

Alan Milburn is now taking the stage at the event where he is launching his report, at Google’s HQ in London.

He starts by saying it is wrong to write off young people as a snowflake generation.

It’s absolutely the reverse of that. It really is. It’s a generation that is full of potential. It’s full of aspiration. It should be full of hope.

And he thanks all those involved in helping him produce the report.

View image in fullscreenAlan Milburn speaking at the launch of his report. Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PAThis table from the report illustrates the point mentioned in the DWP briefing about how public spending per head for pensioners has gone up far more than public spending per head for children over the past two decades. (See 11.38am.)

View image in fullscreenHow public spending per pensioner has increased compared to public spending per child. Photograph: Alan Milburn reportThe Alan Milburn report is now available online here.

And this is what the DWP says in its briefing about how public spending has been skewed towards pensioners rather than young people over the past two decades

-UK spending on employment policies fell from 0.3% of GDP in 2010/11 to 0.1% in 2025/26. Matching Dutch spending on incentives and subsidies would need roughly £6bn more a year, and matching Denmark around £27bn.

-Spending per pensioner is up 55% in real terms between 2004/05 and 2023/24 (to £31,000), compared with 20% for spending per child (to £18,000). The gap has grown 170%.

-The current Youth Guarantee investment (£600m a year) is only 17% of the Youth Training Scheme’s investment (1980s) and 46% of the New Deal’s (late 1990s and early 2000s), in 2026 prices.

-Youth health and disability benefits have risen from £1.7bn in 2019/20 to £4.7bn in 2025/26. They are forecast to reach £8.8bn by 2036/37.

-Youth health and disability benefits account for only 13% of working-age claimants. The overall working-age disability and incapacity bill rose from £37.7bn in 2018/19 to £55bn in 2024/25 (up 46% in real terms), and is forecast to reach £68bn by 2030/31.

In a briefing issued alongside the report, the Department for Work and Pensions has published these figures summing up what it says are the key costings and projected impact figures from the report.

-Neet rate target: around 5% by 2036 (“Neet Zero”). The report’s package models 6.8%, against 13.4% without reform.

-Around 440,000 young people helped into work by 2036.

-Around 0.4% added to GDP per year by 2036.

-Net incomes of young people up by over £2bn. Relative poverty after housing costs down by 50,000.

-£500m of initial investment in 2027/28, by reprioritising existing spend.

-£5.8bn annual investment by 2036/37, offset by £3.6bn of welfare savings and £2.4bbn of extra tax revenue and reduced benefit payments.

-£13.7bn cumulative welfare savings by 2036/37.

-£1.1bn a year employer incentive package, which could help support 170,000 extra job and apprenticeship opportunities.

-Initial 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places, and a path towards 270,000 under-25 apprenticeship starts a year by 2036.

-An additional 150,000 18 to 24 year olds in further education.

-Benefits to employment support spend ratio projected to move from £25 to £1 to £2 to £1 within 10 years.

-Around 100 local authorities have set up Neet taskforces since the interim report.

And this chart, from the Milburn report, explains what the annual costs and savings would be after 10 years.

Fox Style News Syndicate. Sourced from broadcast reporting: Read Full Source Coverage.